From 01ab3cf3fae3ae5d8fa669c0e3b0dd6b5dec96dc Mon Sep 17 00:00:00 2001 From: catlog22 Date: Sat, 24 Jan 2026 11:10:31 +0800 Subject: [PATCH] feat: enhance tdd-verify command with detailed compliance reporting and validation improvements --- .claude/commands/workflow/tdd-verify.md | 583 ++++++++++++++++-------- 1 file changed, 384 insertions(+), 199 deletions(-) diff --git a/.claude/commands/workflow/tdd-verify.md b/.claude/commands/workflow/tdd-verify.md index 0b320dcb..c6af5e9b 100644 --- a/.claude/commands/workflow/tdd-verify.md +++ b/.claude/commands/workflow/tdd-verify.md @@ -1,214 +1,301 @@ --- name: tdd-verify -description: Verify TDD workflow compliance against Red-Green-Refactor cycles, generate quality report with coverage analysis - -argument-hint: "[optional: WFS-session-id]" -allowed-tools: SlashCommand(*), TodoWrite(*), Read(*), Bash(gemini:*) +description: Verify TDD workflow compliance against Red-Green-Refactor cycles. Generates quality report with coverage analysis and quality gate recommendation. Orchestrates sub-commands for comprehensive validation. +argument-hint: "[optional: --session WFS-session-id]" +allowed-tools: SlashCommand(*), TodoWrite(*), Read(*), Write(*), Bash(*), Glob(*) --- # TDD Verification Command (/workflow:tdd-verify) +## Goal + +Verify TDD workflow execution quality by validating Red-Green-Refactor cycle compliance, test coverage completeness, and task chain structure integrity. This command orchestrates multiple analysis phases and generates a comprehensive compliance report with quality gate recommendation. + +**Output**: A structured Markdown report saved to `.workflow/active/WFS-{session}/TDD_COMPLIANCE_REPORT.md` containing: +- Executive summary with compliance score and quality gate recommendation +- Task chain validation (TEST → IMPL → REFACTOR structure) +- Test coverage metrics (line, branch, function) +- Red-Green-Refactor cycle verification +- Best practices adherence assessment +- Actionable improvement recommendations + +## Operating Constraints + +**ORCHESTRATOR MODE**: +- This command coordinates multiple sub-commands (`/workflow:tools:tdd-coverage-analysis`, `ccw cli`) +- MAY write output files: TDD_COMPLIANCE_REPORT.md (primary report), .process/*.json (intermediate artifacts) +- MUST NOT modify source task files or implementation code +- MUST NOT create or delete tasks in the workflow + +**Quality Gate Authority**: The compliance report provides a binding recommendation (BLOCK_MERGE / REQUIRE_FIXES / PROCEED_WITH_CAVEATS / APPROVED) based on objective compliance criteria. + ## Coordinator Role **This command is a pure orchestrator**: Execute 4 phases to verify TDD workflow compliance, test coverage, and Red-Green-Refactor cycle execution. ## Core Responsibilities -- Verify TDD task chain structure -- Analyze test coverage -- Validate TDD cycle execution -- Generate compliance report +- Verify TDD task chain structure (TEST → IMPL → REFACTOR) +- Analyze test coverage metrics +- Validate TDD cycle execution quality +- Generate compliance report with quality gate recommendation ## Execution Process ``` Input Parsing: └─ Decision (session argument): - ├─ session-id provided → Use provided session - └─ No session-id → Auto-detect active session + ├─ --session provided → Use provided session + └─ No session → Auto-detect active session -Phase 1: Session Discovery - ├─ Validate session directory exists - └─ TodoWrite: Mark phase 1 completed +Phase 1: Session Discovery & Validation + ├─ Detect or validate session directory + ├─ Check required artifacts exist (.task/*.json, .summaries/*) + └─ ERROR if invalid or incomplete -Phase 2: Task Chain Validation +Phase 2: Task Chain Structure Validation ├─ Load all task JSONs from .task/ - ├─ Extract task IDs and group by feature - ├─ Validate TDD structure: - │ ├─ TEST-N.M → IMPL-N.M → REFACTOR-N.M chain - │ ├─ Dependency verification - │ └─ Meta field validation (tdd_phase, agent) - └─ TodoWrite: Mark phase 2 completed + ├─ Validate TDD structure: TEST-N.M → IMPL-N.M → REFACTOR-N.M + ├─ Verify dependencies (depends_on) + ├─ Validate meta fields (tdd_phase, agent) + └─ Extract chain validation data -Phase 3: Test Execution Analysis - └─ /workflow:tools:tdd-coverage-analysis - ├─ Coverage metrics extraction - ├─ TDD cycle verification - └─ Compliance score calculation +Phase 3: Coverage & Cycle Analysis + ├─ Call: /workflow:tools:tdd-coverage-analysis + ├─ Parse: test-results.json, coverage-report.json, tdd-cycle-report.md + └─ Extract coverage metrics and TDD cycle verification Phase 4: Compliance Report Generation - ├─ Gemini analysis for comprehensive report + ├─ Aggregate findings from Phases 1-3 + ├─ Calculate compliance score (0-100) + ├─ Determine quality gate recommendation ├─ Generate TDD_COMPLIANCE_REPORT.md - └─ Return summary to user + └─ Display summary to user ``` ## 4-Phase Execution -### Phase 1: Session Discovery -**Auto-detect or use provided session** +### Phase 1: Session Discovery & Validation +**Step 1.1: Detect Session** ```bash -# If session-id provided -sessionId = argument +IF --session parameter provided: + session_id = provided session +ELSE: + # Auto-detect active session + active_sessions = bash(find .workflow/active/ -name "WFS-*" -type d 2>/dev/null) + IF active_sessions is empty: + ERROR: "No active workflow session found. Use --session " + EXIT + ELSE IF active_sessions has multiple entries: + # Use most recently modified session + session_id = bash(ls -td .workflow/active/WFS-*/ 2>/dev/null | head -1 | xargs basename) + ELSE: + session_id = basename(active_sessions[0]) -# Else auto-detect active session -find .workflow/active/ -name "WFS-*" -type d | head -1 | sed 's/.*\///' +# Derive paths +session_dir = .workflow/active/WFS-{session_id} +task_dir = session_dir/.task +summaries_dir = session_dir/.summaries +process_dir = session_dir/.process ``` -**Extract**: sessionId +**Step 1.2: Validate Required Artifacts** +```bash +# Check task files exist +task_files = Glob(task_dir/*.json) +IF task_files.count == 0: + ERROR: "No task JSON files found. Run /workflow:tdd-plan first" + EXIT -**Validation**: Session directory exists +# Check summaries exist (optional but recommended for full analysis) +summaries_exist = EXISTS(summaries_dir) +IF NOT summaries_exist: + WARNING: "No .summaries/ directory found. Some analysis may be limited." +``` -**TodoWrite**: Mark phase 1 completed, phase 2 in_progress +**Output**: session_id, session_dir, task_files list --- -### Phase 2: Task Chain Validation -**Validate TDD structure using bash commands** +### Phase 2: Task Chain Structure Validation +**Step 2.1: Load and Parse Task JSONs** ```bash -# Load all task JSONs -for task_file in .workflow/active/{sessionId}/.task/*.json; do - cat "$task_file" -done +# Single-pass JSON extraction using jq +validation_data = bash(""" +# Load all tasks and extract structured data +cd '{session_dir}/.task' -# Extract task IDs -for task_file in .workflow/active/{sessionId}/.task/*.json; do - cat "$task_file" | jq -r '.id' -done +# Extract all task IDs +task_ids=$(jq -r '.id' *.json 2>/dev/null | sort) -# Check dependencies - read tasks and filter for IMPL/REFACTOR -for task_file in .workflow/active/{sessionId}/.task/IMPL-*.json; do - cat "$task_file" | jq -r '.context.depends_on[]?' -done +# Extract dependencies for IMPL tasks +impl_deps=$(jq -r 'select(.id | startswith("IMPL")) | .id + ":" + (.context.depends_on[]? // "none")' *.json 2>/dev/null) -for task_file in .workflow/active/{sessionId}/.task/REFACTOR-*.json; do - cat "$task_file" | jq -r '.context.depends_on[]?' -done +# Extract dependencies for REFACTOR tasks +refactor_deps=$(jq -r 'select(.id | startswith("REFACTOR")) | .id + ":" + (.context.depends_on[]? // "none")' *.json 2>/dev/null) -# Check meta fields -for task_file in .workflow/active/{sessionId}/.task/*.json; do - cat "$task_file" | jq -r '.meta.tdd_phase' -done +# Extract meta fields +meta_tdd=$(jq -r '.id + ":" + (.meta.tdd_phase // "missing")' *.json 2>/dev/null) +meta_agent=$(jq -r '.id + ":" + (.meta.agent // "missing")' *.json 2>/dev/null) -for task_file in .workflow/active/{sessionId}/.task/*.json; do - cat "$task_file" | jq -r '.meta.agent' -done +# Output as JSON +jq -n --arg ids "$task_ids" \\ + --arg impl "$impl_deps" \\ + --arg refactor "$refactor_deps" \\ + --arg tdd "$meta_tdd" \\ + --arg agent "$meta_agent" \\ + '{ids: $ids, impl_deps: $impl, refactor_deps: $refactor, tdd: $tdd, agent: $agent}' +""") ``` -**Validation**: -- For each feature N, verify TEST-N.M → IMPL-N.M → REFACTOR-N.M exists -- IMPL-N.M.context.depends_on includes TEST-N.M -- REFACTOR-N.M.context.depends_on includes IMPL-N.M -- TEST tasks have tdd_phase="red" and agent="@code-review-test-agent" -- IMPL/REFACTOR tasks have tdd_phase="green"/"refactor" and agent="@code-developer" +**Step 2.2: Validate TDD Chain Structure** +``` +Parse validation_data JSON and validate: -**Extract**: Chain validation report +For each feature N (extracted from task IDs): + 1. TEST-N.M exists? + 2. IMPL-N.M exists? + 3. REFACTOR-N.M exists? (optional but recommended) + 4. IMPL-N.M.context.depends_on contains TEST-N.M? + 5. REFACTOR-N.M.context.depends_on contains IMPL-N.M? + 6. TEST-N.M.meta.tdd_phase == "red"? + 7. TEST-N.M.meta.agent == "@code-review-test-agent"? + 8. IMPL-N.M.meta.tdd_phase == "green"? + 9. IMPL-N.M.meta.agent == "@code-developer"? + 10. REFACTOR-N.M.meta.tdd_phase == "refactor"? -**TodoWrite**: Mark phase 2 completed, phase 3 in_progress +Calculate: +- chain_completeness_score = (complete_chains / total_chains) * 100 +- dependency_accuracy = (correct_deps / total_deps) * 100 +- meta_field_accuracy = (correct_meta / total_meta) * 100 +``` + +**Output**: chain_validation_report (JSON structure with validation results) --- -### Phase 3: Test Execution Analysis -**Command**: `SlashCommand(command="/workflow:tools:tdd-coverage-analysis --session [sessionId]")` +### Phase 3: Coverage & Cycle Analysis -**Input**: sessionId from Phase 1 +**Step 3.1: Call Coverage Analysis Sub-command** +```bash +SlashCommand(command="/workflow:tools:tdd-coverage-analysis --session {session_id}") +``` -**Parse Output**: -- Coverage metrics (line, branch, function percentages) -- TDD cycle verification results -- Compliance score +**Step 3.2: Parse Output Files** +```bash +# Check required outputs exist +IF NOT EXISTS(process_dir/test-results.json): + WARNING: "test-results.json not found. Coverage analysis incomplete." + coverage_data = null +ELSE: + coverage_data = Read(process_dir/test-results.json) -**Validation**: -- `.workflow/active/{sessionId}/.process/test-results.json` exists -- `.workflow/active/{sessionId}/.process/coverage-report.json` exists -- `.workflow/active/{sessionId}/.process/tdd-cycle-report.md` exists +IF NOT EXISTS(process_dir/coverage-report.json): + WARNING: "coverage-report.json not found. Coverage metrics incomplete." + metrics = null +ELSE: + metrics = Read(process_dir/coverage-report.json) -**TodoWrite**: Mark phase 3 completed, phase 4 in_progress +IF NOT EXISTS(process_dir/tdd-cycle-report.md): + WARNING: "tdd-cycle-report.md not found. Cycle validation incomplete." + cycle_data = null +ELSE: + cycle_data = Read(process_dir/tdd-cycle-report.md) +``` + +**Step 3.3: Extract Coverage Metrics** +``` +If coverage_data exists: + - line_coverage_percent + - branch_coverage_percent + - function_coverage_percent + - uncovered_files (list) + - uncovered_lines (map: file -> line ranges) + +If cycle_data exists: + - red_phase_compliance (tests failed initially?) + - green_phase_compliance (tests pass after impl?) + - refactor_phase_compliance (tests stay green during refactor?) + - minimal_implementation_score (was impl minimal?) +``` + +**Output**: coverage_analysis, cycle_analysis --- ### Phase 4: Compliance Report Generation -**Gemini analysis for comprehensive TDD compliance report** +**Step 4.1: Calculate Compliance Score** +``` +Base Score: 100 points + +Deductions: +Chain Structure: + - Missing TEST task: -30 points per feature + - Missing IMPL task: -30 points per feature + - Missing REFACTOR task: -10 points per feature + - Wrong dependency: -15 points per error + - Wrong agent: -5 points per error + - Wrong tdd_phase: -5 points per error + +TDD Cycle Compliance: + - Test didn't fail initially: -10 points per feature + - Tests didn't pass after IMPL: -20 points per feature + - Tests broke during REFACTOR: -15 points per feature + - Over-engineered IMPL: -10 points per feature + +Coverage Quality: + - Line coverage < 80%: -5 points + - Branch coverage < 70%: -5 points + - Function coverage < 80%: -5 points + - Critical paths uncovered: -10 points + +Final Score: Max(0, Base Score - Total Deductions) +``` + +**Step 4.2: Determine Quality Gate** +``` +IF score >= 90 AND no_critical_violations: + recommendation = "APPROVED" +ELSE IF score >= 70 AND critical_violations == 0: + recommendation = "PROCEED_WITH_CAVEATS" +ELSE IF score >= 50: + recommendation = "REQUIRE_FIXES" +ELSE: + recommendation = "BLOCK_MERGE" +``` + +**Step 4.3: Generate Report** ```bash -ccw cli -p " -PURPOSE: Generate TDD compliance report -TASK: Analyze TDD workflow execution and generate quality report -CONTEXT: @{.workflow/active/{sessionId}/.task/*.json,.workflow/active/{sessionId}/.summaries/*,.workflow/active/{sessionId}/.process/tdd-cycle-report.md} -EXPECTED: -- TDD compliance score (0-100) -- Chain completeness verification -- Test coverage analysis summary -- Quality recommendations -- Red-Green-Refactor cycle validation -- Best practices adherence assessment -RULES: Focus on TDD best practices and workflow adherence. Be specific about violations and improvements. -" --tool gemini --mode analysis --cd project-root > .workflow/active/{sessionId}/TDD_COMPLIANCE_REPORT.md +report_content = Generate markdown report (see structure below) +report_path = "{session_dir}/TDD_COMPLIANCE_REPORT.md" +Write(report_path, report_content) ``` -**Output**: TDD_COMPLIANCE_REPORT.md - -**TodoWrite**: Mark phase 4 completed - -**Return to User**: -``` -TDD Verification Report - Session: {sessionId} - -## Chain Validation -[COMPLETE] Feature 1: TEST-1.1 → IMPL-1.1 → REFACTOR-1.1 (Complete) -[COMPLETE] Feature 2: TEST-2.1 → IMPL-2.1 → REFACTOR-2.1 (Complete) -[INCOMPLETE] Feature 3: TEST-3.1 → IMPL-3.1 (Missing REFACTOR phase) - -## Test Execution -All TEST tasks produced failing tests -All IMPL tasks made tests pass -All REFACTOR tasks maintained green tests - -## Coverage Metrics -Line Coverage: {percentage}% -Branch Coverage: {percentage}% -Function Coverage: {percentage}% - -## Compliance Score: {score}/100 - -Detailed report: .workflow/active/{sessionId}/TDD_COMPLIANCE_REPORT.md - -Recommendations: -- Complete missing REFACTOR-3.1 task -- Consider additional edge case tests for Feature 2 -- Improve test failure message clarity in Feature 1 +**Step 4.4: Display Summary to User** +```bash +echo "=== TDD Verification Complete ===" +echo "Session: {session_id}" +echo "Report: {report_path}" +echo "" +echo "Quality Gate: {recommendation}" +echo "Compliance Score: {score}/100" +echo "" +echo "Chain Validation: {chain_completeness_score}%" +echo "Line Coverage: {line_coverage}%" +echo "Branch Coverage: {branch_coverage}%" +echo "" +echo "Next: Review full report for detailed findings" ``` -## TodoWrite Pattern +## TodoWrite Pattern (Optional) + +**Note**: As an orchestrator command, TodoWrite tracking is optional and primarily useful for long-running verification processes. For most cases, the 4-phase execution is fast enough that progress tracking adds noise without value. ```javascript -// Initialize (before Phase 1) -TodoWrite({todos: [ - {"content": "Identify target session", "status": "in_progress", "activeForm": "Identifying target session"}, - {"content": "Validate task chain structure", "status": "pending", "activeForm": "Validating task chain structure"}, - {"content": "Analyze test execution", "status": "pending", "activeForm": "Analyzing test execution"}, - {"content": "Generate compliance report", "status": "pending", "activeForm": "Generating compliance report"} -]}) - -// After Phase 1 -TodoWrite({todos: [ - {"content": "Identify target session", "status": "completed", "activeForm": "Identifying target session"}, - {"content": "Validate task chain structure", "status": "in_progress", "activeForm": "Validating task chain structure"}, - {"content": "Analyze test execution", "status": "pending", "activeForm": "Analyzing test execution"}, - {"content": "Generate compliance report", "status": "pending", "activeForm": "Generating compliance report"} -]}) - -// Continue pattern for Phase 2, 3, 4... +// Only use TodoWrite for complex multi-session verification +// Skip for single-session verification ``` ## Validation Logic @@ -229,27 +316,24 @@ TodoWrite({todos: [ 5. Report incomplete or invalid chains ``` -### Compliance Scoring -``` -Base Score: 100 points +### Quality Gate Criteria -Deductions: -- Missing TEST task: -30 points per feature -- Missing IMPL task: -30 points per feature -- Missing REFACTOR task: -10 points per feature -- Wrong dependency: -15 points per error -- Wrong agent: -5 points per error -- Wrong tdd_phase: -5 points per error -- Test didn't fail initially: -10 points per feature -- Tests didn't pass after IMPL: -20 points per feature -- Tests broke during REFACTOR: -15 points per feature +| Recommendation | Score Range | Critical Violations | Action | +|----------------|-------------|---------------------|--------| +| **APPROVED** | ≥90 | 0 | Safe to merge | +| **PROCEED_WITH_CAVEATS** | ≥70 | 0 | Can proceed, address minor issues | +| **REQUIRE_FIXES** | ≥50 | Any | Must fix before merge | +| **BLOCK_MERGE** | <50 | Any | Block merge until resolved | -Final Score: Max(0, Base Score - Deductions) -``` +**Critical Violations**: +- Missing TEST or IMPL task for any feature +- Tests didn't fail initially (Red phase violation) +- Tests didn't pass after IMPL (Green phase violation) +- Tests broke during REFACTOR (Refactor phase violation) ## Output Files ``` -.workflow/active/{session-id}/ +.workflow/active/WFS-{session-id}/ ├── TDD_COMPLIANCE_REPORT.md # Comprehensive compliance report ⭐ └── .process/ ├── test-results.json # From tdd-coverage-analysis @@ -262,14 +346,14 @@ Final Score: Max(0, Base Score - Deductions) ### Session Discovery Errors | Error | Cause | Resolution | |-------|-------|------------| -| No active session | No WFS-* directories | Provide session-id explicitly | -| Multiple active sessions | Multiple WFS-* directories | Provide session-id explicitly | +| No active session | No WFS-* directories | Provide --session explicitly | +| Multiple active sessions | Multiple WFS-* directories | Provide --session explicitly | | Session not found | Invalid session-id | Check available sessions | ### Validation Errors | Error | Cause | Resolution | |-------|-------|------------| -| Task files missing | Incomplete planning | Run tdd-plan first | +| Task files missing | Incomplete planning | Run /workflow:tdd-plan first | | Invalid JSON | Corrupted task files | Regenerate tasks | | Missing summaries | Tasks not executed | Execute tasks before verify | @@ -278,13 +362,13 @@ Final Score: Max(0, Base Score - Deductions) |-------|-------|------------| | Coverage tool missing | No test framework | Configure testing first | | Tests fail to run | Code errors | Fix errors before verify | -| Gemini analysis fails | Token limit / API error | Retry or reduce context | +| Sub-command fails | tdd-coverage-analysis error | Check sub-command logs | ## Integration & Usage ### Command Chain - **Called After**: `/workflow:execute` (when TDD tasks completed) -- **Calls**: `/workflow:tools:tdd-coverage-analysis`, Gemini CLI +- **Calls**: `/workflow:tools:tdd-coverage-analysis` - **Related**: `/workflow:tdd-plan`, `/workflow:status` ### Basic Usage @@ -293,7 +377,7 @@ Final Score: Max(0, Base Score - Deductions) /workflow:tdd-verify # Specify session -/workflow:tdd-verify WFS-auth +/workflow:tdd-verify --session WFS-auth ``` ### When to Use @@ -308,61 +392,125 @@ Final Score: Max(0, Base Score - Deductions) # TDD Compliance Report - {Session ID} **Generated**: {timestamp} -**Session**: {sessionId} +**Session**: WFS-{sessionId} **Workflow Type**: TDD +--- + ## Executive Summary -Overall Compliance Score: {score}/100 -Status: {EXCELLENT | GOOD | NEEDS IMPROVEMENT | FAILED} + +### Quality Gate Decision + +| Metric | Value | Status | +|--------|-------|--------| +| Compliance Score | {score}/100 | {status_emoji} | +| Chain Completeness | {percentage}% | {status} | +| Line Coverage | {percentage}% | {status} | +| Branch Coverage | {percentage}% | {status} | +| Function Coverage | {percentage}% | {status} | + +### Recommendation + +**{RECOMMENDATION}** + +**Decision Rationale**: +{brief explanation based on score and violations} + +**Quality Gate Criteria**: +- **APPROVED**: Score ≥90, no critical violations +- **PROCEED_WITH_CAVEATS**: Score ≥70, no critical violations +- **REQUIRE_FIXES**: Score ≥50 or critical violations exist +- **BLOCK_MERGE**: Score <50 + +--- ## Chain Analysis ### Feature 1: {Feature Name} -**Status**: Complete +**Status**: ✅ Complete **Chain**: TEST-1.1 → IMPL-1.1 → REFACTOR-1.1 -- **Red Phase**: Test created and failed with clear message -- **Green Phase**: Minimal implementation made test pass -- **Refactor Phase**: Code improved, tests remained green +| Phase | Task | Status | Details | +|-------|------|--------|---------| +| Red | TEST-1.1 | ✅ Pass | Test created and failed with clear message | +| Green | IMPL-1.1 | ✅ Pass | Minimal implementation made test pass | +| Refactor | REFACTOR-1.1 | ✅ Pass | Code improved, tests remained green | ### Feature 2: {Feature Name} -**Status**: Incomplete +**Status**: ⚠️ Incomplete **Chain**: TEST-2.1 → IMPL-2.1 (Missing REFACTOR-2.1) -- **Red Phase**: Test created and failed -- **Green Phase**: Implementation seems over-engineered -- **Refactor Phase**: Missing +| Phase | Task | Status | Details | +|-------|------|--------|---------| +| Red | TEST-2.1 | ✅ Pass | Test created and failed | +| Green | IMPL-2.1 | ⚠️ Warning | Implementation seems over-engineered | +| Refactor | REFACTOR-2.1 | ❌ Missing | Task not completed | **Issues**: -- REFACTOR-2.1 task not completed -- IMPL-2.1 implementation exceeded minimal scope +- REFACTOR-2.1 task not completed (-10 points) +- IMPL-2.1 implementation exceeded minimal scope (-10 points) -[Repeat for all features] +### Chain Validation Summary + +| Metric | Value | +|--------|-------| +| Total Features | {count} | +| Complete Chains | {count} ({percent}%) | +| Incomplete Chains | {count} | +| Missing TEST | {count} | +| Missing IMPL | {count} | +| Missing REFACTOR | {count} | +| Dependency Errors | {count} | +| Meta Field Errors | {count} | + +--- ## Test Coverage Analysis ### Coverage Metrics -- Line Coverage: {percentage}% {status} -- Branch Coverage: {percentage}% {status} -- Function Coverage: {percentage}% {status} + +| Metric | Coverage | Target | Status | +|--------|----------|--------|--------| +| Line Coverage | {percentage}% | ≥80% | {status} | +| Branch Coverage | {percentage}% | ≥70% | {status} | +| Function Coverage | {percentage}% | ≥80% | {status} | ### Coverage Gaps -- {file}:{lines} - Uncovered error handling -- {file}:{lines} - Uncovered edge case + +| File | Lines | Issue | Priority | +|------|-------|-------|----------| +| src/auth/service.ts | 45-52 | Uncovered error handling | HIGH | +| src/utils/parser.ts | 78-85 | Uncovered edge case | MEDIUM | + +--- ## TDD Cycle Validation ### Red Phase (Write Failing Test) -- {N}/{total} features had failing tests initially -- Feature 3: No evidence of initial test failure +- {N}/{total} features had failing tests initially ({percent}%) +- ✅ Compliant features: {list} +- ❌ Non-compliant features: {list} + +**Violations**: +- Feature 3: No evidence of initial test failure (-10 points) ### Green Phase (Make Test Pass) -- {N}/{total} implementations made tests pass -- All implementations minimal and focused +- {N}/{total} implementations made tests pass ({percent}%) +- ✅ Compliant features: {list} +- ❌ Non-compliant features: {list} + +**Violations**: +- Feature 2: Implementation over-engineered (-10 points) ### Refactor Phase (Improve Quality) -- {N}/{total} features completed refactoring -- Feature 2, 4: Refactoring step skipped +- {N}/{total} features completed refactoring ({percent}%) +- ✅ Compliant features: {list} +- ❌ Non-compliant features: {list} + +**Violations**: +- Feature 2, 4: Refactoring step skipped (-20 points total) + +--- ## Best Practices Assessment @@ -377,24 +525,61 @@ Status: {EXCELLENT | GOOD | NEEDS IMPROVEMENT | FAILED} - Missing refactoring steps - Test failure messages could be more descriptive +--- + +## Detailed Findings by Severity + +### Critical Issues ({count}) +{List of critical issues with impact and remediation} + +### High Priority Issues ({count}) +{List of high priority issues with impact and remediation} + +### Medium Priority Issues ({count}) +{List of medium priority issues with impact and remediation} + +### Low Priority Issues ({count}) +{List of low priority issues with impact and remediation} + +--- + ## Recommendations -### High Priority +### Required Fixes (Before Merge) 1. Complete missing REFACTOR tasks (Features 2, 4) 2. Verify initial test failures for Feature 3 -3. Simplify over-engineered implementations +3. Fix tests that broke during refactoring -### Medium Priority -1. Add edge case tests for Features 1, 3 -2. Improve test failure message clarity -3. Increase branch coverage to >85% +### Recommended Improvements +1. Simplify over-engineered implementations +2. Add edge case tests for Features 1, 3 +3. Improve test failure message clarity +4. Increase branch coverage to >85% -### Low Priority +### Optional Enhancements 1. Add more descriptive test names 2. Consider parameterized tests for similar scenarios 3. Document TDD process learnings -## Conclusion -{Summary of compliance status and next steps} +--- + +## Metrics Summary + +| Metric | Value | +|--------|-------| +| Total Features | {count} | +| Complete Chains | {count} ({percent}%) | +| Compliance Score | {score}/100 | +| Critical Issues | {count} | +| High Issues | {count} | +| Medium Issues | {count} | +| Low Issues | {count} | +| Line Coverage | {percent}% | +| Branch Coverage | {percent}% | +| Function Coverage | {percent}% | + +--- + +**Report End** ```