docs: clarify CLI command intent and add output routing

- **Intent Clarification**: Distinguished analysis (read-only) from execution (modifies code) commands
- **Output Routing**: Added comprehensive output destination logic for all CLI commands
- **Scratchpad Integration**: Introduced `.workflow/.scratchpad/` for non-session-specific outputs

## Analysis Commands (Read-Only)
- `/cli:analyze`, `/cli:chat`, `/cli:mode:*`: Added "Core Behavior" emphasizing read-only nature
- Added "MODE: analysis" in command templates
- Examples clearly show recommendations vs. code changes

## Execution Commands (Modifies Code)
- `/cli:execute`: Added ⚠️ warnings about code modification
- `/cli:codex-execute`: Clarified multi-stage execution with detailed output structure
- Both commands now have "Output Routing" sections

## Workflow Architecture Updates
- Added `.workflow/.scratchpad/` directory definition
- Output routing logic: session-relevant → `.chat/`, otherwise → `.scratchpad/`
- File naming pattern: `[command-type]-[brief-description]-[timestamp].md`
- Examples for both analysis and implementation commands

## Key Improvements
- Prevents confusion between analysis and implementation operations
- Solves output loss when no active session exists
- Prevents unrelated analyses from cluttering session history
- Provides centralized location for ad-hoc outputs

🤖 Generated with [Claude Code](https://claude.com/claude-code)

Co-Authored-By: Claude <noreply@anthropic.com>
This commit is contained in:
catlog22
2025-10-05 12:22:23 +08:00
parent 12034c8be5
commit 2dbf550420
9 changed files with 556 additions and 378 deletions

View File

@@ -1,258 +0,0 @@
---
name: workflow:status
description: Generate on-demand views from JSON task data
usage: /workflow:status [task-id] [--format=<format>] [--validate]
argument-hint: [optional: task-id, format, validation]
examples:
- /workflow:status
- /workflow:status impl-1
- /workflow:status --format=hierarchy
- /workflow:status --validate
---
# Workflow Status Command (/workflow:status)
## Overview
Generates on-demand views from JSON task data. No synchronization needed - all views are calculated from the current state of JSON files.
## Core Principles
**Data Source:** @~/.claude/workflows/workflow-architecture.md
## Key Features
### Pure View Generation
- **No Sync**: Views are generated, not synchronized
- **Always Current**: Reads latest JSON data every time
- **No Persistence**: Views are temporary, not saved
- **Single Source**: All data comes from JSON files only
### Multiple View Formats
- **Overview** (default): Current tasks and status
- **Hierarchy**: Task relationships and structure
- **Details**: Specific task information
## Usage
### Default Overview
```bash
/workflow:status
```
Generates current workflow overview:
```markdown
# Workflow Overview
**Session**: WFS-user-auth
**Phase**: IMPLEMENT
**Type**: medium
## Active Tasks
- [⚠️] impl-1: Build authentication module (code-developer)
- [⚠️] impl-2: Setup user management (code-developer)
## Completed Tasks
- [✅] impl-0: Project setup
## Stats
- **Total**: 8 tasks
- **Completed**: 3
- **Active**: 2
- **Remaining**: 3
```
### Specific Task View
```bash
/workflow:status impl-1
```
Shows detailed task information:
```markdown
# Task: impl-1
**Title**: Build authentication module
**Status**: active
**Agent**: @code-developer
**Type**: feature
## Context
- **Requirements**: JWT authentication, OAuth2 support
- **Scope**: src/auth/*, tests/auth/*
- **Acceptance**: Module handles JWT tokens, OAuth2 flow implemented
- **Inherited From**: WFS-user-auth
## Relations
- **Parent**: none
- **Subtasks**: impl-1.1, impl-1.2
- **Dependencies**: impl-0
## Execution
- **Attempts**: 0
- **Last Attempt**: never
## Metadata
- **Created**: 2025-09-05T10:30:00Z
- **Updated**: 2025-09-05T10:35:00Z
```
### Hierarchy View
```bash
/workflow:status --format=hierarchy
```
Shows task relationships:
```markdown
# Task Hierarchy
## Main Tasks
- impl-0: Project setup ✅
- impl-1: Build authentication module ⚠️
- impl-1.1: Design auth schema
- impl-1.2: Implement auth logic
- impl-2: Setup user management ⚠️
## Dependencies
- impl-1 → depends on → impl-0
- impl-2 → depends on → impl-1
```
## View Generation Process
### Data Loading
```pseudo
function generate_workflow_status(task_id, format):
// Load all current data
session = load_workflow_session()
all_tasks = load_all_task_json_files()
// Filter if specific task requested
if task_id:
target_task = find_task(all_tasks, task_id)
return generate_task_detail_view(target_task)
// Generate requested format
switch format:
case 'hierarchy':
return generate_hierarchy_view(all_tasks)
default:
return generate_overview(session, all_tasks)
```
### Real-Time Calculation
- **Task Counts**: Calculated from JSON file status fields
- **Relationships**: Built from JSON relations fields
- **Status**: Read directly from current JSON state
## Validation Mode
### Basic Validation
```bash
/workflow:status --validate
```
Performs integrity checks:
```markdown
# Validation Results
## JSON File Validation
✅ All task JSON files are valid
✅ Session file is valid and readable
## Relationship Validation
✅ All parent-child relationships are valid
✅ All dependencies reference existing tasks
✅ No circular dependencies detected
## Hierarchy Validation
✅ Task hierarchy within depth limits (max 3 levels)
✅ All subtask references are bidirectional
## Issues Found
⚠️ impl-3: No subtasks defined (expected for leaf task)
**Status**: All systems operational
```
### Validation Checks
- **JSON Schema**: All files parse correctly
- **References**: All task IDs exist
- **Hierarchy**: Parent-child relationships are valid
- **Dependencies**: No circular dependencies
- **Depth**: Task hierarchy within limits
## Error Handling
### Missing Files
```bash
❌ Session file not found
→ Initialize new workflow session? (y/n)
❌ Task impl-5 not found
→ Available tasks: impl-1, impl-2, impl-3, impl-4
```
### Invalid Data
```bash
❌ Invalid JSON in impl-2.json
→ Cannot generate view for impl-2
→ Repair file manually or recreate task
⚠️ Circular dependency detected: impl-1 → impl-2 → impl-1
→ Task relationships may be incorrect
```
## Performance Benefits
### Fast Generation
- **No File Writes**: Only reads JSON files
- **No Sync Logic**: No complex synchronization
- **Instant Results**: Generate views on demand
- **No Conflicts**: No state consistency issues
### Scalability
- **Large Task Sets**: Handles hundreds of tasks efficiently
- **Complex Hierarchies**: No performance degradation
- **Concurrent Access**: Multiple views can be generated simultaneously
## Integration
### Workflow Integration
- Use after task creation to see current state
- Use for debugging task relationships
### Command Integration
```bash
# Common workflow
/task:create "New feature"
/workflow:status # Check current state
/task:breakdown impl-1
/workflow:status --format=hierarchy # View new structure
/task:execute impl-1.1
```
## Output Formats
### Supported Formats
- `overview` (default): General workflow status
- `hierarchy`: Task relationships
- `tasks`: Simple task list
- `details`: Comprehensive information
### Custom Filtering
```bash
# Show only active tasks
/workflow:status --format=tasks --filter=active
# Show completed tasks only
/workflow:status --format=tasks --filter=completed
# Show tasks for specific agent
/workflow:status --format=tasks --agent=@code-developer
```
## Related Commands
- `/task:create` - Create tasks (generates JSON data)
- `/task:execute` - Execute tasks (updates JSON data)
- `/task:breakdown` - Create subtasks (generates more JSON data)
- `/workflow:vibe` - Coordinate agents (uses workflow status for coordination)
This workflow status system provides instant, accurate views of workflow state without any synchronization complexity or performance overhead.