From ab7bf32263b5999614d57a8a31e59dd3365def26 Mon Sep 17 00:00:00 2001 From: Claude Date: Thu, 20 Nov 2025 11:31:06 +0000 Subject: [PATCH] docs: add comprehensive orchestrator parameter pass-through validation report - Checked 11 orchestrator commands for parameter transparency - Validated parameter flow across all workflow phases - Confirmed correct parameter passing to sub-commands - All orchestrators pass validation with no issues found - Categories: workflow planning, test generation, UI design, memory management, session management --- orchestrator-param-check-report.md | 277 +++++++++++++++++++++++++++++ 1 file changed, 277 insertions(+) create mode 100644 orchestrator-param-check-report.md diff --git a/orchestrator-param-check-report.md b/orchestrator-param-check-report.md new file mode 100644 index 00000000..c0687d10 --- /dev/null +++ b/orchestrator-param-check-report.md @@ -0,0 +1,277 @@ +# 编排器命令参数透传检查报告 + +生成时间: 2025-11-20 + +## 检查范围 + +检查所有通过 SlashCommand 工具调用其他 slash commands 的编排器命令，验证参数是否正确透传。 + +## 检查结果总结 + +✅ **所有编排器命令参数透传正确** + +已检查 11 个编排器命令，未发现参数透传错误。 + +--- + +## 详细检查清单 + +### 1. `/memory:skill-memory` (4-Phase Orchestrator) + +**文件**: `.claude/commands/memory/skill-memory.md` + +**调用的命令**: +- Phase 2: `/memory:docs [targetPath] --tool [tool] --mode [mode] [--cli-execute]` +- Phase 3: `/workflow:execute` + +**参数透传验证**: +- ✅ `[targetPath]` - Phase 1 获取 → Phase 2 透传 +- ✅ `--tool` - 用户参数 → Phase 2 透传 +- ✅ `--mode` - 用户参数 → Phase 2 透传 +- ✅ `--cli-execute` - 用户参数 → Phase 2 透传 + +**状态**: ✅ 正确 + +--- + +### 2. `/workflow:plan` (5-Phase Orchestrator) + +**文件**: `.claude/commands/workflow/plan.md` + +**调用的命令**: +- Phase 1: `/workflow:session:start --auto "[structured-task-description]"` +- Phase 2: `/workflow:tools:context-gather --session [sessionId] "[structured-task-description]"` +- Phase 3: `/workflow:tools:conflict-resolution --session [sessionId] --context [contextPath]` (conditional) +- Phase 4: `/workflow:tools:task-generate-agent --session [sessionId] [--cli-execute]` + +**参数透传验证**: +- ✅ `[structured-task-description]` - 用户输入 → Phase 1, 2 +- ✅ `[sessionId]` - Phase 1 输出 → Phase 2, 3, 4 +- ✅ `[contextPath]` - Phase 2 输出 → Phase 3 +- ✅ `--cli-execute` - 用户参数 → Phase 4 + +**状态**: ✅ 正确 + +--- + +### 3. `/workflow:test-gen` (5-Phase Orchestrator) + +**文件**: `.claude/commands/workflow/test-gen.md` + +**调用的命令**: +- Phase 1: `/workflow:session:start --new "Test validation for [sourceSessionId]"` +- Phase 2: `/workflow:tools:test-context-gather --session [testSessionId]` +- Phase 3: `/workflow:tools:test-concept-enhanced --session [testSessionId] --context [testContextPath]` +- Phase 4: `/workflow:tools:test-task-generate [--use-codex] [--cli-execute] --session [testSessionId]` + +**参数透传验证**: +- ✅ `[sourceSessionId]` - 用户输入 → Phase 1 +- ✅ `[testSessionId]` - Phase 1 输出 → Phase 2, 3, 4 +- ✅ `[testContextPath]` - Phase 2 输出 → Phase 3 +- ✅ `--use-codex` - 用户参数 → Phase 4 +- ✅ `--cli-execute` - 用户参数 → Phase 4 + +**状态**: ✅ 正确 + +--- + +### 4. `/workflow:test-fix-gen` (5-Phase Orchestrator) + +**文件**: `.claude/commands/workflow/test-fix-gen.md` + +**调用的命令**: +- Phase 1: `/workflow:session:start --new "..."` +- Phase 2 (Session Mode): `/workflow:tools:test-context-gather --session [testSessionId]` +- Phase 2 (Prompt Mode): `/workflow:tools:context-gather --session [testSessionId] "[task_description]"` +- Phase 3: `/workflow:tools:test-concept-enhanced --session [testSessionId] --context [contextPath]` +- Phase 4: `/workflow:tools:test-task-generate [--use-codex] [--cli-execute] --session [testSessionId]` + +**参数透传验证**: +- ✅ `[testSessionId]` - Phase 1 输出 → Phase 2, 3, 4 +- ✅ `[task_description]` - 用户输入 → Phase 2 (Prompt Mode) +- ✅ `[contextPath]` - Phase 2 输出 → Phase 3 +- ✅ `--use-codex` - 用户参数 → Phase 4 +- ✅ `--cli-execute` - 用户参数 → Phase 4 + +**状态**: ✅ 正确 + +--- + +### 5. `/workflow:ui-design:codify-style` (4-Phase Orchestrator) + +**文件**: `.claude/commands/workflow/ui-design/codify-style.md` + +**调用的命令**: +- Phase 1: `/workflow:ui-design:import-from-code --design-id [temp_id] --source [source]` +- Phase 2: `/workflow:ui-design:reference-page-generator --design-run [design_run_path] --package-name [package_name] --output-dir [output_dir]` + +**参数透传验证**: +- ✅ `[temp_id]` - Phase 0 生成 → Phase 1 +- ✅ `[source]` - 用户参数 → Phase 1 +- ✅ `[design_run_path]` - Phase 1 输出 → Phase 2 +- ✅ `[package_name]` - 用户参数 → Phase 2 +- ✅ `[output_dir]` - 用户参数 → Phase 2 + +**状态**: ✅ 正确 + +--- + +### 6. `/workflow:ui-design:explore-auto` (10-Phase Orchestrator) + +**文件**: `.claude/commands/workflow/ui-design/explore-auto.md` + +**调用的命令**: +- Phase 6: `/workflow:ui-design:import-from-code --design-id [design_id] --source [code_base_path]` (conditional) +- Phase 7: `/workflow:ui-design:style-extract --design-id [design_id] [--images "..."] [--prompt "..."] --variants [style_variants] --interactive` +- Phase 8: `/workflow:ui-design:animation-extract --design-id [design_id] [--images "..."] [--prompt "..."] --interactive` (conditional) +- Phase 9: `/workflow:ui-design:layout-extract --design-id [design_id] [--images "..."] [--prompt "..."] --targets [targets_string] --variants [layout_variants] --device-type [device_type] --interactive` +- Phase 10: `/workflow:ui-design:generate --design-id [design_id] [--session ...]` + +**参数透传验证**: +- ✅ `[design_id]` - Phase 4 生成 → Phase 6, 7, 8, 9, 10 +- ✅ `[code_base_path]` - Phase 1 检测 → Phase 6 +- ✅ `[images_input]` - 用户参数 → Phase 7, 8, 9 +- ✅ `[prompt_text]` - 用户参数 → Phase 7, 8, 9 +- ✅ `[style_variants]` - Phase 2 解析 → Phase 7 +- ✅ `[layout_variants]` - Phase 2 解析 → Phase 9 +- ✅ `[targets_string]` - Phase 5 确认 → Phase 9 +- ✅ `[device_type]` - Phase 3 推断 → Phase 9 +- ✅ `[session_id]` - 用户参数 → Phase 10 (optional) + +**状态**: ✅ 正确 + +--- + +### 7. `/workflow:ui-design:imitate-auto` (5-Phase Orchestrator) + +**文件**: `.claude/commands/workflow/ui-design/imitate-auto.md` + +**调用的命令**: +- Phase 0.5: `/workflow:ui-design:import-from-code --design-id [design_id] --source [code_base_path]` (conditional) +- Phase 2: `/workflow:ui-design:style-extract --design-id [design_id] [--images "..."] [--prompt "..."] --variants 1 --refine --interactive` +- Phase 2.3: `/workflow:ui-design:animation-extract --design-id [design_id] [--images "..."] [--prompt "..."] --refine --interactive` +- Phase 2.5: `/workflow:ui-design:layout-extract --design-id [design_id] [--images "..."] [--prompt "..."] --targets "home" --variants 1 --refine --interactive` +- Phase 3: `/workflow:ui-design:generate --design-id [design_id]` +- Phase 4: `/workflow:ui-design:update --session [session_id]` (conditional) + +**参数透传验证**: +- ✅ `[design_id]` - Phase 0 生成 → 所有阶段 +- ✅ `[code_base_path]` - Phase 0 检测 → Phase 0.5 +- ✅ `[images_input]` - 用户参数 → Phase 2, 2.3, 2.5 +- ✅ `[prompt_text]` - 用户参数 → Phase 2, 2.3, 2.5 +- ✅ `[session_id]` - 用户参数 → Phase 4 (optional) + +**状态**: ✅ 正确 + +--- + +### 8. `/workflow:tdd-plan` (6-Phase Orchestrator) + +**文件**: `.claude/commands/workflow/tdd-plan.md` + +**调用的命令**: +- Phase 1: `/workflow:session:start --auto "TDD: [structured-description]"` +- Phase 2: `/workflow:tools:context-gather --session [sessionId] "TDD: [structured-description]"` +- Phase 3: `/workflow:tools:test-context-gather --session [sessionId]` +- Phase 4: `/workflow:tools:conflict-resolution --session [sessionId] --context [contextPath]` (conditional) +- Phase 5 (Agent Mode): `/workflow:tools:task-generate-tdd --session [sessionId]` +- Phase 5 (CLI Mode): `/workflow:tools:task-generate-tdd --session [sessionId] --cli-execute` + +**参数透传验证**: +- ✅ `[structured-description]` - 用户输入处理 → Phase 1, 2 +- ✅ `[sessionId]` - Phase 1 输出 → Phase 2, 3, 4, 5 +- ✅ `[contextPath]` - Phase 2 输出 → Phase 4 +- ✅ `--cli-execute` - 用户参数 → Phase 5 + +**状态**: ✅ 正确 + +--- + +### 9. `/memory:workflow-skill-memory` (Agent-Based Orchestrator) + +**文件**: `.claude/commands/memory/workflow-skill-memory.md` + +**调用的命令**: +- 主要使用 Task 工具调用 universal-executor agents +- Integration 部分: 被 `/workflow:session:complete` 调用 + - `SlashCommand(command="/memory:workflow-skill-memory session {session_id}")` + +**参数透传验证**: +- ✅ `{session_id}` - 正确透传给 workflow-skill-memory + +**状态**: ✅ 正确 + +--- + +### 10. `/workflow:lite-plan` (5-Phase Orchestrator) + +**文件**: `.claude/commands/workflow/lite-plan.md` + +**调用的命令**: +- Phase 5: `/workflow:lite-execute --in-memory` + +**参数透传验证**: +- ✅ `--in-memory` - 固定参数，通过 executionContext 内存变量传递完整上下文 + +**状态**: ✅ 正确 + +--- + +### 11. `/workflow:session:start` (Initialization Orchestrator) + +**文件**: `.claude/commands/workflow/session/start.md` + +**调用的命令**: +- Step 0 (首次初始化): `/workflow:init` + +**参数透传验证**: +- ✅ `/workflow:init` 无需参数，用于项目级别初始化 + +**状态**: ✅ 正确 + +--- + +## 检查方法 + +1. **搜索范围**: 搜索所有包含 `SlashCommand` 调用的命令文件 +2. **验证标准**: + - 用户输入参数是否正确传递给子命令 + - 阶段间输出是否正确传递给下一阶段 + - 可选参数是否按条件正确透传 + - 参数格式是否匹配子命令要求 +3. **关注要点**: + - 参数变量名是否一致 + - 可选参数 (如 `--cli-execute`) 是否正确传递 + - 条件参数 (如 `--session`) 是否按逻辑透传 + - 阶段输出路径是否正确传递 + +--- + +## 结论 + +✅ **所有编排器命令参数透传正确** + +检查了 11 个编排器命令，涵盖: +- Workflow planning orchestrators (plan, tdd-plan, lite-plan) +- Test generation orchestrators (test-gen, test-fix-gen) +- UI design orchestrators (explore-auto, imitate-auto, codify-style) +- Memory management orchestrators (skill-memory, workflow-skill-memory) +- Session management orchestrators (session:start) + +所有命令的参数透传逻辑符合设计规范，未发现错误或遗漏。 + +--- + +## 建议 + +虽然当前所有编排器参数透传正确，但为了保持代码质量，建议: + +1. **添加参数验证**: 在每个 phase 开始前验证必需参数是否存在 +2. **统一错误处理**: 规范参数缺失或格式错误时的错误信息 +3. **文档完善**: 为每个编排器添加参数流图，清晰展示参数在各 phase 间的传递 +4. **自动化测试**: 考虑为关键编排器添加参数透传的单元测试 + +--- + +**检查人员**: Claude (Sonnet 4.5) +**检查完成时间**: 2025-11-20