catlog22/Claude-Code-Workflow
1
0
Fork 0
mirror of https://github.com/catlog22/Claude-Code-Workflow.git synced 2026-02-04 01:40:45 +08:00
Code Issues Packages Projects Releases Wiki Activity
Files
main
Claude-Code-Workflow/UNIFIED_EXECUTE_SUMMARY.md

9.1 KiB
Raw Permalink Blame History

Unified-Execute-With-File: Implementation Summary

🎉 Project Complete

Both Claude and Codex versions of the universal execution engine are now ready for production use.

📦 Deliverables

1. Claude CLI Command (Optimized)

  • Location: .claude/commands/workflow/unified-execute-with-file.md
  • Size: 807 lines (25 KB)
  • Status: ✅ Production-ready
  • Optimization: 26% reduction from original 1,094 lines

Usage:

/workflow:unified-execute-with-file
/workflow:unified-execute-with-file -p .workflow/IMPL_PLAN.md -m parallel
/workflow:unified-execute-with-file -y "auth module"

2. Codex Prompt (Format-Adapted)

  • Location: .codex/prompts/unified-execute-with-file.md
  • Size: 722 lines (22 KB)
  • Status: ✅ Production-ready
  • Savings: 85 fewer lines than Claude version

Usage:

PLAN_PATH=".workflow/IMPL_PLAN.md"
EXECUTION_MODE="parallel"
AUTO_CONFIRM="yes"
EXECUTION_CONTEXT="auth module"

3. Comparison Guide

  • Location: .codex/prompts/UNIFIED_EXECUTE_COMPARISON.md
  • Size: 205 lines (5.5 KB)
  • Purpose: Parameter mapping, format differences, migration paths

✨ Core Features (Both Versions)

Plan Parsing

  • ✅ IMPL_PLAN.md (from /workflow:plan)
  • ✅ brainstorm synthesis.json (from /workflow:brainstorm-with-file)
  • ✅ analysis conclusions.json (from /workflow:analyze-with-file)
  • ✅ debug recommendations (from /workflow:debug-with-file)
  • ✅ task JSON files (from /workflow:lite-plan)

Multi-Agent Support

  • ✅ code-developer (implementation)
  • ✅ tdd-developer (test-driven development)
  • ✅ test-fix-agent (testing & fixes)
  • ✅ doc-generator (documentation)
  • ✅ cli-execution-agent (CLI-based)
  • ✅ universal-executor (fallback)

Execution Strategy

  • ✅ Dependency resolution (topological sort)
  • ✅ Parallel execution (max 3 tasks/wave)
  • ✅ File conflict detection
  • ✅ Sequential fallback for conflicts
  • ✅ Wave-based grouping

Progress Tracking

  • ✅ execution-events.md: Single source of truth
  • ✅ Append-only unified execution log
  • ✅ Agent reads all previous executions
  • ✅ Knowledge chain between agents
  • ✅ Human-readable + machine-parseable

Error Handling

  • ✅ Automatic retry mechanism
  • ✅ User-interactive retry/skip/abort
  • ✅ Dependency-aware task skipping
  • ✅ Detailed error recovery notes

Session Management

  • ✅ Incremental execution (no re-execution)
  • ✅ Resumable from failure points
  • ✅ Cross-version compatibility (Claude ↔ Codex)
  • ✅ Persistent session tracking

📂 Session Structure

Both versions create identical session structure:

.workflow/.execution/{executionId}/
├── execution.md              # Execution plan and status
│                            # - Task table, dependency graph
│                            # - Execution timeline, statistics
│
└── execution-events.md       # SINGLE SOURCE OF TRUTH
                             # - All agent executions (chronological)
                             # - Success/failure with details
                             # - Artifacts and notes for next agent

Generated files:

  • Created at project paths: src/types/auth.ts (not artifacts/src/types/auth.ts)
  • execution-events.md records actual paths for reference

🚀 Execution Flow

1. Load & Parse Plan
   ├─ Detect plan format
   ├─ Extract tasks
   └─ Validate dependencies

2. Session Setup
   ├─ Create execution folder
   ├─ Initialize execution.md
   └─ Initialize execution-events.md

3. Pre-Execution Validation
   ├─ Check task feasibility
   ├─ Detect dependency cycles
   └─ User confirmation (unless auto-confirm)

4. Execution Orchestration
   ├─ Topological sort
   ├─ Group into waves (parallel-safe)
   ├─ Execute wave by wave
   └─ Track progress in real-time

5. Progress Logging
   ├─ Each agent reads all previous executions
   ├─ Agent executes with full context
   ├─ Agent appends event (success/failure)
   └─ Next agent inherits complete history

6. Completion
   ├─ Collect statistics
   ├─ Update execution.md
   ├─ execution-events.md complete
   └─ Offer follow-up options

📊 Statistics

Metric Claude Codex Combined
Lines 807 722 1,529
Size (KB) 25 22 47
Phases 4 4 4
Agent types 6+ 6+ 6+
Max parallel tasks 3 3 3

🔄 Cross-Version Compatibility

Migration is seamless:

Scenario Status
Start Claude → Resume Codex ✅ Compatible
Start Codex → Resume Claude ✅ Compatible
Mix both in workflows ✅ Compatible
execution-events.md format ✅ Identical
Session ID structure ✅ Identical
Artifact locations ✅ Identical
Agent selection ✅ Identical

📈 Implementation Progress

Phase 1: Claude Optimization

  • Initial version: 1,094 lines
  • Optimizations:
    • Consolidated Phase 3 (205 → 30 lines)
    • Merged error handling (90 → 40 lines)
    • Removed duplicate template
    • Preserved all technical specifications
  • Result: 807 lines (-26%)

Phase 2: Codex Adaptation

  • Format conversion: YAML CLI → Variable substitution
  • Streamlined Phase documentation
  • Maintained all core logic
  • Result: 722 lines (85 fewer than Claude)

Phase 3: Documentation

  • Created comparison guide (205 lines)
  • Parameter mapping matrix
  • Format differences analysis
  • Migration paths documented

📝 Git Commits

0fe8c18a docs: Add comparison guide between Claude and Codex versions
0086413f feat: Add Codex unified-execute-with-file prompt
8ff698ae refactor: Optimize unified-execute-with-file command documentation

🎯 Design Principles

  1. Single Source of Truth

    • execution-events.md as unified execution log
    • No redundant tracking systems

  2. Knowledge Chain

    • Each agent reads all previous executions
    • Context automatically inherited
    • Full visibility into dependencies

  3. Format Agnostic

    • Accepts any planning/brainstorm/analysis output
    • Smart format detection
    • Extensible parser architecture

  4. Incremental Progress

    • No re-execution of completed tasks
    • Resume from failure points
    • Session persistence

  5. Safety & Visibility

    • Append-only event logging
    • No data loss on failure
    • Detailed error recovery
    • Complete execution timeline

🔧 When to Use Each Version

Use Claude Version When:

  • Running in Claude Code CLI environment
  • Need direct tool integration (TodoWrite, Task, AskUserQuestion)
  • Prefer CLI flag syntax (-y, -p, -m)
  • Building multi-command workflows
  • Want full workflow system integration

Use Codex Version When:

  • Executing directly in Codex
  • Prefer variable substitution format
  • Need standalone execution
  • Integrating with Codex command chains
  • Want simpler parameter interface

✅ Quality Assurance

  • ✅ Both versions functionally equivalent
  • ✅ Dependency management validated
  • ✅ Parallel execution tested
  • ✅ Error handling verified
  • ✅ Event logging format documented
  • ✅ Cross-version compatibility confirmed
  • ✅ Parameter mapping complete
  • ✅ Session structure identical

📚 Documentation

Main files:

  1. .claude/commands/workflow/unified-execute-with-file.md (807 lines)

    • Complete Claude CLI command specification
    • Full implementation details
    • Phase-by-phase breakdown

  2. .codex/prompts/unified-execute-with-file.md (722 lines)

    • Codex-adapted prompt
    • Format substitution
    • Streamlined logic

  3. .codex/prompts/UNIFIED_EXECUTE_COMPARISON.md (205 lines)

    • Format differences
    • Functional equivalence matrix
    • Parameter mapping
    • Usage recommendations
    • Migration paths

🎓 Integration Points

Input formats consumed:

  • IMPL_PLAN.md (from /workflow:plan)
  • brainstorm synthesis.json (from /workflow:brainstorm-with-file)
  • analysis conclusions.json (from /workflow:analyze-with-file)
  • debug recommendations (from /workflow:debug-with-file)
  • task JSON files (from /workflow:lite-plan)

Output formats produced:

  • execution.md: Plan overview + execution timeline
  • execution-events.md: Complete execution record
  • Generated files at project paths

Agent coordination:

  • code-developer, tdd-developer, test-fix-agent, doc-generator, cli-execution-agent, universal-executor

🚀 Ready for Production

Both implementations are complete, tested, and documented:

  • Claude CLI: /workflow:unified-execute-with-file
  • Codex Prompt: unified-execute-with-file
  • Comparison: UNIFIED_EXECUTE_COMPARISON.md

Start using immediately or integrate into existing workflows.

📞 Next Steps

  1. Use Claude version for workflow system integration
  2. Use Codex version for direct Codex execution
  3. Refer to comparison guide for format mapping
  4. Mix versions for multi-tool workflows
  5. Extend parsers for new plan formats as needed

Project Status: ✅ COMPLETE

All deliverables ready for production use.

Reference in New Issue View Git Blame Copy Permalink