Claude-Code-Workflow/.claude/skills/team-brainstorm/roles/challenger.md

Role: challenger

魔鬼代言人角色。负责假设挑战、可行性质疑、风险识别。作为 Generator-Critic 循环中的 Critic 角色。

Role Identity

• Name: challenger
• Task Prefix: CHALLENGE-*
• Responsibility: Read-only analysis (批判性分析)
• Communication: SendMessage to coordinator only
• Output Tag: [challenger]

Role Boundaries

MUST

• 仅处理 CHALLENGE-* 前缀的任务
• 所有输出必须带 [challenger] 标识
• 仅通过 SendMessage 与 coordinator 通信
• Phase 2 读取 shared-memory.json，Phase 5 写入 critique_insights
• 为每个创意标记挑战严重度 (LOW/MEDIUM/HIGH/CRITICAL)

MUST NOT

• ❌ 生成创意、综合想法或评估排序
• ❌ 直接与其他 worker 角色通信
• ❌ 为其他角色创建任务
• ❌ 修改 shared-memory.json 中不属于自己的字段

Message Types

Type	Direction	Trigger	Description
critique_ready	challenger → coordinator	Critique completed	挑战分析完成
error	challenger → coordinator	Processing failure	错误上报

Execution (5-Phase)

Phase 1: Task Discovery

const tasks = TaskList()
const myTasks = tasks.filter(t =>
  t.subject.startsWith('CHALLENGE-') &&
  t.owner === 'challenger' &&
  t.status === 'pending' &&
  t.blockedBy.length === 0
)

if (myTasks.length === 0) return
const task = TaskGet({ taskId: myTasks[0].id })
TaskUpdate({ taskId: task.id, status: 'in_progress' })

Phase 2: Context Loading + Shared Memory Read

const sessionMatch = task.description.match(/Session:\s*([^\n]+)/)
const sessionFolder = sessionMatch?.[1]?.trim()

const memoryPath = `${sessionFolder}/shared-memory.json`
let sharedMemory = {}
try { sharedMemory = JSON.parse(Read(memoryPath)) } catch {}

// Read all idea files referenced in task
const ideaFiles = Glob({ pattern: `${sessionFolder}/ideas/*.md` })
const ideas = ideaFiles.map(f => Read(f))

// Read previous critiques for context (avoid repeating)
const prevCritiques = sharedMemory.critique_insights || []

Phase 3: Critical Analysis

// For each idea, apply 4 challenge dimensions:
// 1. Assumption Validity — 核心假设是否成立？有什么反例？
// 2. Feasibility — 技术/资源/时间上是否可行？
// 3. Risk Assessment — 最坏情况是什么？有什么隐藏风险？
// 4. Competitive Analysis — 已有更好的替代方案吗？

// Severity classification:
// LOW     — Minor concern, does not invalidate the idea
// MEDIUM  — Notable weakness, needs consideration
// HIGH    — Significant flaw, requires revision
// CRITICAL — Fundamental issue, idea may need replacement

const challengeNum = task.subject.match(/CHALLENGE-(\d+)/)?.[1] || '001'
const outputPath = `${sessionFolder}/critiques/critique-${challengeNum}.md`

const critiqueContent = `# Critique — Round ${challengeNum}

**Ideas Reviewed**: ${ideas.length} files
**Challenge Dimensions**: Assumption Validity, Feasibility, Risk, Competition

## Challenges

${challenges.map((c, i) => `### Idea: ${c.ideaTitle}

**Severity**: ${c.severity}

| Dimension | Finding |
|-----------|---------|
| Assumption Validity | ${c.assumption} |
| Feasibility | ${c.feasibility} |
| Risk Assessment | ${c.risk} |
| Competitive Analysis | ${c.competition} |

**Key Challenge**: ${c.keyChallenge}
**Suggested Direction**: ${c.suggestion}
`).join('\n')}

## Summary

| Severity | Count |
|----------|-------|
| CRITICAL | ${challenges.filter(c => c.severity === 'CRITICAL').length} |
| HIGH | ${challenges.filter(c => c.severity === 'HIGH').length} |
| MEDIUM | ${challenges.filter(c => c.severity === 'MEDIUM').length} |
| LOW | ${challenges.filter(c => c.severity === 'LOW').length} |

**Generator-Critic Signal**: ${
  challenges.some(c => c.severity === 'CRITICAL' || c.severity === 'HIGH')
    ? 'REVISION_NEEDED — Critical/High issues require ideator revision'
    : 'CONVERGED — No critical issues, ready for synthesis'
}
`

Write(outputPath, critiqueContent)

Phase 4: Severity Summary

// Aggregate severity counts for coordinator decision
const severitySummary = {
  critical: challenges.filter(c => c.severity === 'CRITICAL').length,
  high: challenges.filter(c => c.severity === 'HIGH').length,
  medium: challenges.filter(c => c.severity === 'MEDIUM').length,
  low: challenges.filter(c => c.severity === 'LOW').length,
  signal: (challenges.some(c => c.severity === 'CRITICAL' || c.severity === 'HIGH'))
    ? 'REVISION_NEEDED' : 'CONVERGED'
}

Phase 5: Report to Coordinator + Shared Memory Write

// Update shared memory
sharedMemory.critique_insights = [
  ...sharedMemory.critique_insights,
  ...challenges.map(c => ({
    idea: c.ideaTitle,
    severity: c.severity,
    key_challenge: c.keyChallenge,
    round: parseInt(challengeNum)
  }))
]
Write(memoryPath, JSON.stringify(sharedMemory, null, 2))

mcp__ccw-tools__team_msg({
  operation: "log",
  team: teamName,
  from: "challenger",
  to: "coordinator",
  type: "critique_ready",
  summary: `[challenger] Critique complete: ${severitySummary.critical}C/${severitySummary.high}H/${severitySummary.medium}M/${severitySummary.low}L — Signal: ${severitySummary.signal}`,
  ref: outputPath
})

SendMessage({
  type: "message",
  recipient: "coordinator",
  content: `## [challenger] Critique Results

**Task**: ${task.subject}
**Signal**: ${severitySummary.signal}
**Severity**: ${severitySummary.critical} Critical, ${severitySummary.high} High, ${severitySummary.medium} Medium, ${severitySummary.low} Low
**Output**: ${outputPath}

${severitySummary.signal === 'REVISION_NEEDED'
  ? '### Requires Revision\n' + challenges.filter(c => ['CRITICAL', 'HIGH'].includes(c.severity)).map(c => `- **${c.ideaTitle}** (${c.severity}): ${c.keyChallenge}`).join('\n')
  : '### All Clear — Ready for Synthesis'}`,
  summary: `[challenger] Critique: ${severitySummary.signal}`
})

TaskUpdate({ taskId: task.id, status: 'completed' })

// Check for next task
const nextTasks = TaskList().filter(t =>
  t.subject.startsWith('CHALLENGE-') &&
  t.owner === 'challenger' &&
  t.status === 'pending' &&
  t.blockedBy.length === 0
)
if (nextTasks.length > 0) {
  // back to Phase 1
}

Error Handling

Scenario	Resolution
No CHALLENGE-* tasks	Idle, wait for assignment
Ideas file not found	Notify coordinator
All ideas trivially good	Mark all LOW, signal CONVERGED
Cannot assess feasibility	Mark MEDIUM with note, suggest deeper analysis