catlog22/Claude-Code-Workflow
1
0
Fork 0
mirror of https://github.com/catlog22/Claude-Code-Workflow.git synced 2026-02-10 02:24:35 +08:00
Code Issues Packages Projects Releases Wiki Activity

feat: enhance tdd-verify command with detailed compliance reporting and validation improvements

Browse Source
This commit is contained in:
catlog22
2026-01-24 11:10:31 +08:00
parent a2c1b9b47c
commit 01ab3cf3fa
1 changed files with 384 additions and 199 deletions
Download Patch File Download Diff File Expand all files Collapse all files

583
.claude/commands/workflow/tdd-verify.md
View File

@@ -1,214 +1,301 @@
--- ---
name: tdd-verify name: tdd-verify
description: Verify TDD workflow compliance against Red-Green-Refactor cycles, generate quality report with coverage analysis description: Verify TDD workflow compliance against Red-Green-Refactor cycles. Generates quality report with coverage analysis and quality gate recommendation. Orchestrates sub-commands for comprehensive validation.
argument-hint: "[optional: --session WFS-session-id]"
argument-hint: "[optional: WFS-session-id]" allowed-tools: SlashCommand(*), TodoWrite(*), Read(*), Write(*), Bash(*), Glob(*)
allowed-tools: SlashCommand(*), TodoWrite(*), Read(*), Bash(gemini:*)
--- ---
# TDD Verification Command (/workflow:tdd-verify) # TDD Verification Command (/workflow:tdd-verify)
## Goal
Verify TDD workflow execution quality by validating Red-Green-Refactor cycle compliance, test coverage completeness, and task chain structure integrity. This command orchestrates multiple analysis phases and generates a comprehensive compliance report with quality gate recommendation.
**Output**: A structured Markdown report saved to `.workflow/active/WFS-{session}/TDD_COMPLIANCE_REPORT.md` containing:
- Executive summary with compliance score and quality gate recommendation
- Task chain validation (TEST → IMPL → REFACTOR structure)
- Test coverage metrics (line, branch, function)
- Red-Green-Refactor cycle verification
- Best practices adherence assessment
- Actionable improvement recommendations
## Operating Constraints
**ORCHESTRATOR MODE**:
- This command coordinates multiple sub-commands (`/workflow:tools:tdd-coverage-analysis`, `ccw cli`)
- MAY write output files: TDD_COMPLIANCE_REPORT.md (primary report), .process/*.json (intermediate artifacts)
- MUST NOT modify source task files or implementation code
- MUST NOT create or delete tasks in the workflow
**Quality Gate Authority**: The compliance report provides a binding recommendation (BLOCK_MERGE / REQUIRE_FIXES / PROCEED_WITH_CAVEATS / APPROVED) based on objective compliance criteria.
## Coordinator Role ## Coordinator Role
**This command is a pure orchestrator**: Execute 4 phases to verify TDD workflow compliance, test coverage, and Red-Green-Refactor cycle execution. **This command is a pure orchestrator**: Execute 4 phases to verify TDD workflow compliance, test coverage, and Red-Green-Refactor cycle execution.
## Core Responsibilities ## Core Responsibilities
- Verify TDD task chain structure - Verify TDD task chain structure (TEST → IMPL → REFACTOR)
- Analyze test coverage - Analyze test coverage metrics
- Validate TDD cycle execution - Validate TDD cycle execution quality
- Generate compliance report - Generate compliance report with quality gate recommendation
## Execution Process ## Execution Process
``` ```
Input Parsing: Input Parsing:
└─ Decision (session argument): └─ Decision (session argument):
├─ session-id provided → Use provided session ├─ --session provided → Use provided session
└─ No session-id → Auto-detect active session └─ No session → Auto-detect active session
Phase 1: Session Discovery Phase 1: Session Discovery & Validation
├─ Validate session directory exists ├─ Detect or validate session directory
└─ TodoWrite: Mark phase 1 completed ├─ Check required artifacts exist (.task/*.json, .summaries/*)
└─ ERROR if invalid or incomplete
Phase 2: Task Chain Validation Phase 2: Task Chain Structure Validation
├─ Load all task JSONs from .task/ ├─ Load all task JSONs from .task/
├─ Extract task IDs and group by feature ├─ Validate TDD structure: TEST-N.M → IMPL-N.M → REFACTOR-N.M
├─ Validate TDD structure: ├─ Verify dependencies (depends_on)
│ ├─ TEST-N.M → IMPL-N.M → REFACTOR-N.M chain ├─ Validate meta fields (tdd_phase, agent)
│ ├─ Dependency verification └─ Extract chain validation data
│ └─ Meta field validation (tdd_phase, agent)
└─ TodoWrite: Mark phase 2 completed
Phase 3: Test Execution Analysis Phase 3: Coverage & Cycle Analysis
└─ /workflow:tools:tdd-coverage-analysis ├─ Call: /workflow:tools:tdd-coverage-analysis
├─ Coverage metrics extraction ├─ Parse: test-results.json, coverage-report.json, tdd-cycle-report.md
├─ TDD cycle verification └─ Extract coverage metrics and TDD cycle verification
└─ Compliance score calculation
Phase 4: Compliance Report Generation Phase 4: Compliance Report Generation
├─ Gemini analysis for comprehensive report ├─ Aggregate findings from Phases 1-3
├─ Calculate compliance score (0-100)
├─ Determine quality gate recommendation
├─ Generate TDD_COMPLIANCE_REPORT.md ├─ Generate TDD_COMPLIANCE_REPORT.md
└─ Return summary to user └─ Display summary to user
``` ```
## 4-Phase Execution ## 4-Phase Execution
### Phase 1: Session Discovery ### Phase 1: Session Discovery & Validation
**Auto-detect or use provided session**
**Step 1.1: Detect Session**
```bash ```bash
# If session-id provided IF --session parameter provided:
sessionId = argument session_id = provided session
ELSE:
# Auto-detect active session
active_sessions = bash(find .workflow/active/ -name "WFS-*" -type d 2>/dev/null)
IF active_sessions is empty:
ERROR: "No active workflow session found. Use --session <session-id>"
EXIT
ELSE IF active_sessions has multiple entries:
# Use most recently modified session
session_id = bash(ls -td .workflow/active/WFS-*/ 2>/dev/null | head -1 | xargs basename)
ELSE:
session_id = basename(active_sessions[0])
# Else auto-detect active session # Derive paths
find .workflow/active/ -name "WFS-*" -type d | head -1 | sed 's/.*\///' session_dir = .workflow/active/WFS-{session_id}
task_dir = session_dir/.task
summaries_dir = session_dir/.summaries
process_dir = session_dir/.process
``` ```
**Extract**: sessionId **Step 1.2: Validate Required Artifacts**
```bash
# Check task files exist
task_files = Glob(task_dir/*.json)
IF task_files.count == 0:
ERROR: "No task JSON files found. Run /workflow:tdd-plan first"
EXIT
**Validation**: Session directory exists # Check summaries exist (optional but recommended for full analysis)
summaries_exist = EXISTS(summaries_dir)
IF NOT summaries_exist:
WARNING: "No .summaries/ directory found. Some analysis may be limited."
```
**TodoWrite**: Mark phase 1 completed, phase 2 in_progress **Output**: session_id, session_dir, task_files list
--- ---
### Phase 2: Task Chain Validation ### Phase 2: Task Chain Structure Validation
**Validate TDD structure using bash commands**
**Step 2.1: Load and Parse Task JSONs**
```bash ```bash
# Load all task JSONs # Single-pass JSON extraction using jq
for task_file in .workflow/active/{sessionId}/.task/*.json; do validation_data = bash("""
cat "$task_file" # Load all tasks and extract structured data
done cd '{session_dir}/.task'
# Extract task IDs # Extract all task IDs
for task_file in .workflow/active/{sessionId}/.task/*.json; do task_ids=$(jq -r '.id' *.json 2>/dev/null | sort)
cat "$task_file" | jq -r '.id'
done
# Check dependencies - read tasks and filter for IMPL/REFACTOR # Extract dependencies for IMPL tasks
for task_file in .workflow/active/{sessionId}/.task/IMPL-*.json; do impl_deps=$(jq -r 'select(.id | startswith("IMPL")) | .id + ":" + (.context.depends_on[]? // "none")' *.json 2>/dev/null)
cat "$task_file" | jq -r '.context.depends_on[]?'
done
for task_file in .workflow/active/{sessionId}/.task/REFACTOR-*.json; do # Extract dependencies for REFACTOR tasks
cat "$task_file" | jq -r '.context.depends_on[]?' refactor_deps=$(jq -r 'select(.id | startswith("REFACTOR")) | .id + ":" + (.context.depends_on[]? // "none")' *.json 2>/dev/null)
done
# Check meta fields # Extract meta fields
for task_file in .workflow/active/{sessionId}/.task/*.json; do meta_tdd=$(jq -r '.id + ":" + (.meta.tdd_phase // "missing")' *.json 2>/dev/null)
cat "$task_file" | jq -r '.meta.tdd_phase' meta_agent=$(jq -r '.id + ":" + (.meta.agent // "missing")' *.json 2>/dev/null)
done
for task_file in .workflow/active/{sessionId}/.task/*.json; do # Output as JSON
cat "$task_file" | jq -r '.meta.agent' jq -n --arg ids "$task_ids" \\
done --arg impl "$impl_deps" \\
--arg refactor "$refactor_deps" \\
--arg tdd "$meta_tdd" \\
--arg agent "$meta_agent" \\
'{ids: $ids, impl_deps: $impl, refactor_deps: $refactor, tdd: $tdd, agent: $agent}'
""")
``` ```
**Validation**: **Step 2.2: Validate TDD Chain Structure**
- For each feature N, verify TEST-N.M → IMPL-N.M → REFACTOR-N.M exists ```
- IMPL-N.M.context.depends_on includes TEST-N.M Parse validation_data JSON and validate:
- REFACTOR-N.M.context.depends_on includes IMPL-N.M
- TEST tasks have tdd_phase="red" and agent="@code-review-test-agent"
- IMPL/REFACTOR tasks have tdd_phase="green"/"refactor" and agent="@code-developer"
**Extract**: Chain validation report For each feature N (extracted from task IDs):
1. TEST-N.M exists?
2. IMPL-N.M exists?
3. REFACTOR-N.M exists? (optional but recommended)
4. IMPL-N.M.context.depends_on contains TEST-N.M?
5. REFACTOR-N.M.context.depends_on contains IMPL-N.M?
6. TEST-N.M.meta.tdd_phase == "red"?
7. TEST-N.M.meta.agent == "@code-review-test-agent"?
8. IMPL-N.M.meta.tdd_phase == "green"?
9. IMPL-N.M.meta.agent == "@code-developer"?
10. REFACTOR-N.M.meta.tdd_phase == "refactor"?
**TodoWrite**: Mark phase 2 completed, phase 3 in_progress Calculate:
- chain_completeness_score = (complete_chains / total_chains) * 100
- dependency_accuracy = (correct_deps / total_deps) * 100
- meta_field_accuracy = (correct_meta / total_meta) * 100
```
**Output**: chain_validation_report (JSON structure with validation results)
--- ---
### Phase 3: Test Execution Analysis ### Phase 3: Coverage & Cycle Analysis
**Command**: `SlashCommand(command="/workflow:tools:tdd-coverage-analysis --session [sessionId]")`
**Input**: sessionId from Phase 1 **Step 3.1: Call Coverage Analysis Sub-command**
```bash
SlashCommand(command="/workflow:tools:tdd-coverage-analysis --session {session_id}")
```
**Parse Output**: **Step 3.2: Parse Output Files**
- Coverage metrics (line, branch, function percentages) ```bash
- TDD cycle verification results # Check required outputs exist
- Compliance score IF NOT EXISTS(process_dir/test-results.json):
WARNING: "test-results.json not found. Coverage analysis incomplete."
coverage_data = null
ELSE:
coverage_data = Read(process_dir/test-results.json)
**Validation**: IF NOT EXISTS(process_dir/coverage-report.json):
- `.workflow/active/{sessionId}/.process/test-results.json` exists WARNING: "coverage-report.json not found. Coverage metrics incomplete."
- `.workflow/active/{sessionId}/.process/coverage-report.json` exists metrics = null
- `.workflow/active/{sessionId}/.process/tdd-cycle-report.md` exists ELSE:
metrics = Read(process_dir/coverage-report.json)
**TodoWrite**: Mark phase 3 completed, phase 4 in_progress IF NOT EXISTS(process_dir/tdd-cycle-report.md):
WARNING: "tdd-cycle-report.md not found. Cycle validation incomplete."
cycle_data = null
ELSE:
cycle_data = Read(process_dir/tdd-cycle-report.md)
```
**Step 3.3: Extract Coverage Metrics**
```
If coverage_data exists:
- line_coverage_percent
- branch_coverage_percent
- function_coverage_percent
- uncovered_files (list)
- uncovered_lines (map: file -> line ranges)
If cycle_data exists:
- red_phase_compliance (tests failed initially?)
- green_phase_compliance (tests pass after impl?)
- refactor_phase_compliance (tests stay green during refactor?)
- minimal_implementation_score (was impl minimal?)
```
**Output**: coverage_analysis, cycle_analysis
--- ---
### Phase 4: Compliance Report Generation ### Phase 4: Compliance Report Generation
**Gemini analysis for comprehensive TDD compliance report**
**Step 4.1: Calculate Compliance Score**
```
Base Score: 100 points
Deductions:
Chain Structure:
- Missing TEST task: -30 points per feature
- Missing IMPL task: -30 points per feature
- Missing REFACTOR task: -10 points per feature
- Wrong dependency: -15 points per error
- Wrong agent: -5 points per error
- Wrong tdd_phase: -5 points per error
TDD Cycle Compliance:
- Test didn't fail initially: -10 points per feature
- Tests didn't pass after IMPL: -20 points per feature
- Tests broke during REFACTOR: -15 points per feature
- Over-engineered IMPL: -10 points per feature
Coverage Quality:
- Line coverage < 80%: -5 points
- Branch coverage < 70%: -5 points
- Function coverage < 80%: -5 points
- Critical paths uncovered: -10 points
Final Score: Max(0, Base Score - Total Deductions)
```
**Step 4.2: Determine Quality Gate**
```
IF score >= 90 AND no_critical_violations:
recommendation = "APPROVED"
ELSE IF score >= 70 AND critical_violations == 0:
recommendation = "PROCEED_WITH_CAVEATS"
ELSE IF score >= 50:
recommendation = "REQUIRE_FIXES"
ELSE:
recommendation = "BLOCK_MERGE"
```
**Step 4.3: Generate Report**
```bash ```bash
ccw cli -p " report_content = Generate markdown report (see structure below)
PURPOSE: Generate TDD compliance report report_path = "{session_dir}/TDD_COMPLIANCE_REPORT.md"
TASK: Analyze TDD workflow execution and generate quality report Write(report_path, report_content)
CONTEXT: @{.workflow/active/{sessionId}/.task/*.json,.workflow/active/{sessionId}/.summaries/*,.workflow/active/{sessionId}/.process/tdd-cycle-report.md}
EXPECTED:
- TDD compliance score (0-100)
- Chain completeness verification
- Test coverage analysis summary
- Quality recommendations
- Red-Green-Refactor cycle validation
- Best practices adherence assessment
RULES: Focus on TDD best practices and workflow adherence. Be specific about violations and improvements.
" --tool gemini --mode analysis --cd project-root > .workflow/active/{sessionId}/TDD_COMPLIANCE_REPORT.md
``` ```
**Output**: TDD_COMPLIANCE_REPORT.md **Step 4.4: Display Summary to User**
```bash
**TodoWrite**: Mark phase 4 completed echo "=== TDD Verification Complete ==="
echo "Session: {session_id}"
**Return to User**: echo "Report: {report_path}"
``` echo ""
TDD Verification Report - Session: {sessionId} echo "Quality Gate: {recommendation}"
echo "Compliance Score: {score}/100"
## Chain Validation echo ""
[COMPLETE] Feature 1: TEST-1.1 → IMPL-1.1 → REFACTOR-1.1 (Complete) echo "Chain Validation: {chain_completeness_score}%"
[COMPLETE] Feature 2: TEST-2.1 → IMPL-2.1 → REFACTOR-2.1 (Complete) echo "Line Coverage: {line_coverage}%"
[INCOMPLETE] Feature 3: TEST-3.1 → IMPL-3.1 (Missing REFACTOR phase) echo "Branch Coverage: {branch_coverage}%"
echo ""
## Test Execution echo "Next: Review full report for detailed findings"
All TEST tasks produced failing tests
All IMPL tasks made tests pass
All REFACTOR tasks maintained green tests
## Coverage Metrics
Line Coverage: {percentage}%
Branch Coverage: {percentage}%
Function Coverage: {percentage}%
## Compliance Score: {score}/100
Detailed report: .workflow/active/{sessionId}/TDD_COMPLIANCE_REPORT.md
Recommendations:
- Complete missing REFACTOR-3.1 task
- Consider additional edge case tests for Feature 2
- Improve test failure message clarity in Feature 1
``` ```
## TodoWrite Pattern ## TodoWrite Pattern (Optional)
**Note**: As an orchestrator command, TodoWrite tracking is optional and primarily useful for long-running verification processes. For most cases, the 4-phase execution is fast enough that progress tracking adds noise without value.
```javascript ```javascript
// Initialize (before Phase 1) // Only use TodoWrite for complex multi-session verification
TodoWrite({todos: [ // Skip for single-session verification
{"content": "Identify target session", "status": "in_progress", "activeForm": "Identifying target session"},
{"content": "Validate task chain structure", "status": "pending", "activeForm": "Validating task chain structure"},
{"content": "Analyze test execution", "status": "pending", "activeForm": "Analyzing test execution"},
{"content": "Generate compliance report", "status": "pending", "activeForm": "Generating compliance report"}
]})
// After Phase 1
TodoWrite({todos: [
{"content": "Identify target session", "status": "completed", "activeForm": "Identifying target session"},
{"content": "Validate task chain structure", "status": "in_progress", "activeForm": "Validating task chain structure"},
{"content": "Analyze test execution", "status": "pending", "activeForm": "Analyzing test execution"},
{"content": "Generate compliance report", "status": "pending", "activeForm": "Generating compliance report"}
]})
// Continue pattern for Phase 2, 3, 4...
``` ```
## Validation Logic ## Validation Logic
@@ -229,27 +316,24 @@ TodoWrite({todos: [
5. Report incomplete or invalid chains 5. Report incomplete or invalid chains
``` ```
### Compliance Scoring ### Quality Gate Criteria
```
Base Score: 100 points
Deductions: | Recommendation | Score Range | Critical Violations | Action |
- Missing TEST task: -30 points per feature |----------------|-------------|---------------------|--------|
- Missing IMPL task: -30 points per feature | **APPROVED** | ≥90 | 0 | Safe to merge |
- Missing REFACTOR task: -10 points per feature | **PROCEED_WITH_CAVEATS** | ≥70 | 0 | Can proceed, address minor issues |
- Wrong dependency: -15 points per error | **REQUIRE_FIXES** | ≥50 | Any | Must fix before merge |
- Wrong agent: -5 points per error | **BLOCK_MERGE** | <50 | Any | Block merge until resolved |
- Wrong tdd_phase: -5 points per error
- Test didn't fail initially: -10 points per feature
- Tests didn't pass after IMPL: -20 points per feature
- Tests broke during REFACTOR: -15 points per feature
Final Score: Max(0, Base Score - Deductions) **Critical Violations**:
``` - Missing TEST or IMPL task for any feature
- Tests didn't fail initially (Red phase violation)
- Tests didn't pass after IMPL (Green phase violation)
- Tests broke during REFACTOR (Refactor phase violation)
## Output Files ## Output Files
``` ```
.workflow/active/{session-id}/ .workflow/active/WFS-{session-id}/
├── TDD_COMPLIANCE_REPORT.md # Comprehensive compliance report ⭐ ├── TDD_COMPLIANCE_REPORT.md # Comprehensive compliance report ⭐
└── .process/ └── .process/
├── test-results.json # From tdd-coverage-analysis ├── test-results.json # From tdd-coverage-analysis
@@ -262,14 +346,14 @@ Final Score: Max(0, Base Score - Deductions)
### Session Discovery Errors ### Session Discovery Errors
| Error | Cause | Resolution | | Error | Cause | Resolution |
|-------|-------|------------| |-------|-------|------------|
| No active session | No WFS-* directories | Provide session-id explicitly | | No active session | No WFS-* directories | Provide --session explicitly |
| Multiple active sessions | Multiple WFS-* directories | Provide session-id explicitly | | Multiple active sessions | Multiple WFS-* directories | Provide --session explicitly |
| Session not found | Invalid session-id | Check available sessions | | Session not found | Invalid session-id | Check available sessions |
### Validation Errors ### Validation Errors
| Error | Cause | Resolution | | Error | Cause | Resolution |
|-------|-------|------------| |-------|-------|------------|
| Task files missing | Incomplete planning | Run tdd-plan first | | Task files missing | Incomplete planning | Run /workflow:tdd-plan first |
| Invalid JSON | Corrupted task files | Regenerate tasks | | Invalid JSON | Corrupted task files | Regenerate tasks |
| Missing summaries | Tasks not executed | Execute tasks before verify | | Missing summaries | Tasks not executed | Execute tasks before verify |
@@ -278,13 +362,13 @@ Final Score: Max(0, Base Score - Deductions)
|-------|-------|------------| |-------|-------|------------|
| Coverage tool missing | No test framework | Configure testing first | | Coverage tool missing | No test framework | Configure testing first |
| Tests fail to run | Code errors | Fix errors before verify | | Tests fail to run | Code errors | Fix errors before verify |
| Gemini analysis fails | Token limit / API error | Retry or reduce context | | Sub-command fails | tdd-coverage-analysis error | Check sub-command logs |
## Integration & Usage ## Integration & Usage
### Command Chain ### Command Chain
- **Called After**: `/workflow:execute` (when TDD tasks completed) - **Called After**: `/workflow:execute` (when TDD tasks completed)
- **Calls**: `/workflow:tools:tdd-coverage-analysis`, Gemini CLI - **Calls**: `/workflow:tools:tdd-coverage-analysis`
- **Related**: `/workflow:tdd-plan`, `/workflow:status` - **Related**: `/workflow:tdd-plan`, `/workflow:status`
### Basic Usage ### Basic Usage
@@ -293,7 +377,7 @@ Final Score: Max(0, Base Score - Deductions)
/workflow:tdd-verify /workflow:tdd-verify
# Specify session # Specify session
/workflow:tdd-verify WFS-auth /workflow:tdd-verify --session WFS-auth
``` ```
### When to Use ### When to Use
@@ -308,61 +392,125 @@ Final Score: Max(0, Base Score - Deductions)
# TDD Compliance Report - {Session ID} # TDD Compliance Report - {Session ID}
**Generated**: {timestamp} **Generated**: {timestamp}
**Session**: {sessionId} **Session**: WFS-{sessionId}
**Workflow Type**: TDD **Workflow Type**: TDD
---
## Executive Summary ## Executive Summary
Overall Compliance Score: {score}/100
Status: {EXCELLENT | GOOD | NEEDS IMPROVEMENT | FAILED} ### Quality Gate Decision
| Metric | Value | Status |
|--------|-------|--------|
| Compliance Score | {score}/100 | {status_emoji} |
| Chain Completeness | {percentage}% | {status} |
| Line Coverage | {percentage}% | {status} |
| Branch Coverage | {percentage}% | {status} |
| Function Coverage | {percentage}% | {status} |
### Recommendation
**{RECOMMENDATION}**
**Decision Rationale**:
{brief explanation based on score and violations}
**Quality Gate Criteria**:
- **APPROVED**: Score ≥90, no critical violations
- **PROCEED_WITH_CAVEATS**: Score ≥70, no critical violations
- **REQUIRE_FIXES**: Score ≥50 or critical violations exist
- **BLOCK_MERGE**: Score <50
---
## Chain Analysis ## Chain Analysis
### Feature 1: {Feature Name} ### Feature 1: {Feature Name}
**Status**: Complete **Status**: ✅ Complete
**Chain**: TEST-1.1 → IMPL-1.1 → REFACTOR-1.1 **Chain**: TEST-1.1 → IMPL-1.1 → REFACTOR-1.1
- **Red Phase**: Test created and failed with clear message | Phase | Task | Status | Details |
- **Green Phase**: Minimal implementation made test pass |-------|------|--------|---------|
- **Refactor Phase**: Code improved, tests remained green | Red | TEST-1.1 | ✅ Pass | Test created and failed with clear message |
| Green | IMPL-1.1 | ✅ Pass | Minimal implementation made test pass |
| Refactor | REFACTOR-1.1 | ✅ Pass | Code improved, tests remained green |
### Feature 2: {Feature Name} ### Feature 2: {Feature Name}
**Status**: Incomplete **Status**: ⚠️ Incomplete
**Chain**: TEST-2.1 → IMPL-2.1 (Missing REFACTOR-2.1) **Chain**: TEST-2.1 → IMPL-2.1 (Missing REFACTOR-2.1)
- **Red Phase**: Test created and failed | Phase | Task | Status | Details |
- **Green Phase**: Implementation seems over-engineered |-------|------|--------|---------|
- **Refactor Phase**: Missing | Red | TEST-2.1 | ✅ Pass | Test created and failed |
| Green | IMPL-2.1 | ⚠️ Warning | Implementation seems over-engineered |
| Refactor | REFACTOR-2.1 | ❌ Missing | Task not completed |
**Issues**: **Issues**:
- REFACTOR-2.1 task not completed - REFACTOR-2.1 task not completed (-10 points)
- IMPL-2.1 implementation exceeded minimal scope - IMPL-2.1 implementation exceeded minimal scope (-10 points)
[Repeat for all features] ### Chain Validation Summary
| Metric | Value |
|--------|-------|
| Total Features | {count} |
| Complete Chains | {count} ({percent}%) |
| Incomplete Chains | {count} |
| Missing TEST | {count} |
| Missing IMPL | {count} |
| Missing REFACTOR | {count} |
| Dependency Errors | {count} |
| Meta Field Errors | {count} |
---
## Test Coverage Analysis ## Test Coverage Analysis
### Coverage Metrics ### Coverage Metrics
- Line Coverage: {percentage}% {status}
- Branch Coverage: {percentage}% {status} | Metric | Coverage | Target | Status |
- Function Coverage: {percentage}% {status} |--------|----------|--------|--------|
| Line Coverage | {percentage}% | ≥80% | {status} |
| Branch Coverage | {percentage}% | ≥70% | {status} |
| Function Coverage | {percentage}% | ≥80% | {status} |
### Coverage Gaps ### Coverage Gaps
- {file}:{lines} - Uncovered error handling
- {file}:{lines} - Uncovered edge case | File | Lines | Issue | Priority |
|------|-------|-------|----------|
| src/auth/service.ts | 45-52 | Uncovered error handling | HIGH |
| src/utils/parser.ts | 78-85 | Uncovered edge case | MEDIUM |
---
## TDD Cycle Validation ## TDD Cycle Validation
### Red Phase (Write Failing Test) ### Red Phase (Write Failing Test)
- {N}/{total} features had failing tests initially - {N}/{total} features had failing tests initially ({percent}%)
- Feature 3: No evidence of initial test failure - ✅ Compliant features: {list}
- ❌ Non-compliant features: {list}
**Violations**:
- Feature 3: No evidence of initial test failure (-10 points)
### Green Phase (Make Test Pass) ### Green Phase (Make Test Pass)
- {N}/{total} implementations made tests pass - {N}/{total} implementations made tests pass ({percent}%)
- All implementations minimal and focused - ✅ Compliant features: {list}
- ❌ Non-compliant features: {list}
**Violations**:
- Feature 2: Implementation over-engineered (-10 points)
### Refactor Phase (Improve Quality) ### Refactor Phase (Improve Quality)
- {N}/{total} features completed refactoring - {N}/{total} features completed refactoring ({percent}%)
- Feature 2, 4: Refactoring step skipped - ✅ Compliant features: {list}
- ❌ Non-compliant features: {list}
**Violations**:
- Feature 2, 4: Refactoring step skipped (-20 points total)
---
## Best Practices Assessment ## Best Practices Assessment
@@ -377,24 +525,61 @@ Status: {EXCELLENT | GOOD | NEEDS IMPROVEMENT | FAILED}
- Missing refactoring steps - Missing refactoring steps
- Test failure messages could be more descriptive - Test failure messages could be more descriptive
---
## Detailed Findings by Severity
### Critical Issues ({count})
{List of critical issues with impact and remediation}
### High Priority Issues ({count})
{List of high priority issues with impact and remediation}
### Medium Priority Issues ({count})
{List of medium priority issues with impact and remediation}
### Low Priority Issues ({count})
{List of low priority issues with impact and remediation}
---
## Recommendations ## Recommendations
### High Priority ### Required Fixes (Before Merge)
1. Complete missing REFACTOR tasks (Features 2, 4) 1. Complete missing REFACTOR tasks (Features 2, 4)
2. Verify initial test failures for Feature 3 2. Verify initial test failures for Feature 3
3. Simplify over-engineered implementations 3. Fix tests that broke during refactoring
### Medium Priority ### Recommended Improvements
1. Add edge case tests for Features 1, 3 1. Simplify over-engineered implementations
2. Improve test failure message clarity 2. Add edge case tests for Features 1, 3
3. Increase branch coverage to >85% 3. Improve test failure message clarity
4. Increase branch coverage to >85%
### Low Priority ### Optional Enhancements
1. Add more descriptive test names 1. Add more descriptive test names
2. Consider parameterized tests for similar scenarios 2. Consider parameterized tests for similar scenarios
3. Document TDD process learnings 3. Document TDD process learnings
## Conclusion ---
{Summary of compliance status and next steps}
## Metrics Summary
| Metric | Value |
|--------|-------|
| Total Features | {count} |
| Complete Chains | {count} ({percent}%) |
| Compliance Score | {score}/100 |
| Critical Issues | {count} |
| High Issues | {count} |
| Medium Issues | {count} |
| Low Issues | {count} |
| Line Coverage | {percent}% |
| Branch Coverage | {percent}% |
| Function Coverage | {percent}% |
---
**Report End**
``` ```